11 Churches attacked by arsonist, a result from Muslim extremist in
But the very actions of these ‘extremist’ Muslims cum Malays –burning down Churches and their protests towards Christians having the right to use the very word ‘Allah’ to describe GOD in their own publications- in general truly contradict with what is taught in Islam itself and what is being taught and written in the Muslim Book- The Koran itself- which all Muslims profess and believe as The Word of GOD HIMSELF. For in Islam, Christians and Jews/Judaism are called ‘The People of the Book’, and it has been written in the Quran itself…
Chapter 22 Al-Hajj ( The Pilgrimage ) verse 39-40:
39. ‘To those against whom war is made, permission is given ( to fight ) because they are wronged;- and verily, God is Most Powerful for their aid;
40.( They are ) those who have been expelled from their homes in defiance of right,- ( for no cause ) except that they say, “Our LORD is GOD.” Did not GOD check on set of people by means of another, there would surely have been pulled down monasteries, churches, synagogues, and mosques, in which the name of GOD is commemorated in abundant measure. GOD will certainly aid those who aid HIS ( cause ); -for verily GOD is full of Strength, Exalted in Might, ( able to enforce His Will ).’
As seen written clearly, by this verse in the Quran; Islam teaches Muslims to respect the houses of worship of other religions and in particularly those of The People of the Book itself, and despite the language variation of practices among The People of the Book, whether it be in Arabic, Hebrew, Yiddish, or Latin, GOD does not ‘denounce’ in anyway that it is HIS name which is being commemorated in these houses of worship among The People of the Book itself.
Furthermore, the actions among the current ruling political party UMNO in setting up a Group in Facebook called “MENENTANG PENGGUNAAN NAMA ‘ALLAH’ OLEH BUKAN ISLAM” or “ Protest Against the use of the name ‘Allah’ by Non-Muslims’ which gained over hundred thousands fans in just a few days… this action itself is also against what is being taught in the Quran for it is written…
Chapter 29 Al-Ankabut ( The Spider ) verse 46:
“ And dispute you not with the People of the Book, except with means better ( than mere disputation ), unless it be with those of them who inflict wrong ( and injury ): but say,
‘We believe in the Revelation which has come down to us and in what which came down to you; our God and your God is One; and it is to Him we bow ( in Islam ).”
Many ignorant Malay Muslims in Malaysia even question the validity of whether Jews or Christians of today are even ‘qualified’ to be considered as genuine or authentic ‘People of the Book’ in according the Quran and Islam, simply due to the ‘differences’ in religious ‘theology’ between Christians and Muslims, particularly concerning the subject matter of the concept of ‘The Holy Trinity’ in accordance to Christian theology.
But sadly what such ignorant Malay Muslims in Malaysia have failed to comprehend is the fact that such theology had already existed ‘before’ the coming of Islam itself and is already written about in the Quran itself, and NOWHERE within the Quran itself or the Traditions of the Prophet Muhammad ( Peace Be Upon Him ), does GOD deny that the Christians or Jews of today are not the ‘People of The Book’. As much of what is contained within the Bible today, whether it be The Old Testament held by the Jews, or even what is contained in The New Testament today, have all become ‘standard text’ used and practice or ‘canonical’, long before the coming of Islam itself, and the Quran in many verses throughout it- had explained in detail and made clear the differences between itself –The Quran- and The Bible as well as concerning the differences in religious theology between the belief of a Muslim and those of ‘The People of the Book’, thus if Malay Muslims truly read and study their own book The Quran, there would and neither could be no confusion as many of them so called claim, because everything has been written and made clear and concise to Muslims in general.
Furthermore for Muslims it is also written in the Quran where GOD commands Muslims...
Chapter 2 Al-Baqarah ( The Heifer ) verse 136:
‘Say you: “We believe in God, and the revelations given to us, and to Abraham, Ismail, Isaac, Jacob and the Tribes, and that given to Moses and Jesus, and that given to ( all ) prophets from their LORD: we make no difference between one and another of them: and we bow to God ( in Islam ).’
Furthermore in relations between Muslims and The People of the Book, although the differences between theology and belief had been made clear, along with precautions concerning relations for Muslims to guard their faith when mixing or interacting with People of the Book, he Quran also writes…
Chapter 3 Surah Al-Imran ( The Family of Imran ) verse 113-115:
‘113. Not all of them are alike: of the People of the Book are a portion that stand ( for the right ): they rehearse the Signs of GOD all night long, and they prostrate themselves in adoration. 114. They believe in GOD and the Last Day; they enjoin what is right, and forbid what is wrong; and they hasten ( in emulation ) in all good works: they are in the ranks of the righteous. 115. Of the good that they do, nothing will be rejected of them; for GOD knows well those that do right.’
The Quran also writes specifically pertaining to relations with People of the Book among Christians…
Chapter 5 Surah Al-Ma’idah ( The Table ) verse 82:-
‘…and nearest among them in love to the believers will you find those who say.
“We are Christians.”: because amongst these are men devoted to learning and men who have renounced the world, and they are not arrogant.’
But despite everything that has been written so clearly in the Quran, which is held sacred and holy by Muslims worldwide, why have Malay Muslims resorted to extremism and behave in the exact opposite of what has been taught as well as even practiced by the Muslim prophet Muhammad ( PBUH ) himself???
Perhaps one simple answer lies in how Islam is being taught and practiced by the Malay Muslims in
Chapter 46 Al-Ahqaf ( Winding Sand-tracts ) verse 12:
“ And before this, was the Book of Moses as a guide and mercy: and this Book confirms
( it ) in the Arabic tongue: to admonish the unjust, and as Glad Tidings to those who do right.”
Chapter 39 Al-Zumar ( The Crowds ) verse 28:
“ ( It is ) a Quran in Arabic without any crookedness: in order that they may guard against Evil.”
Chapter 43 Al-Zukhruf ( The Gold Adornments ) verse 3:
“ We have made it a Quran in Arabic, that you may be able to understand ( and learn wisdom ).”
From these verses in the Quran alone one could already see the how the wide commotion had been started by the Malay-Muslims in
“How many Malays actually speak or understand Arabic???”
It is quite easy to see why as well as how all the commotion started from such an issue and to be politicized by groups of irresponsible parties, as Arabic is not the primary language of the Malays, nor is it considered a ‘second language’ for Malays with Malaysia being a former British Colony.
Only Malays who attended Islamic Religious Schools from Primary School, or were in
As some of the more ignorant Malays would claim that simply using the very word ‘Allah’ by Christians could cause ‘confusion’. But confusion is caused by only by those with lack of information to begin with, or those who are given the wrong information.
But could one who actually or properly reads and studies the Quran be misinformed? When it has even been written in the Quran itself concerning ‘Allah’…
Chapter 6 Surah Al-An’am ( The Cattle ) verse 103:
‘No vision could grasp Him, but His grasp is over all vision: He is above all comprehension, yet is acquainted with all things.’
From this verse alone it is already made quite clear the difference in the concept of GOD in comparison with that in Christianity or other religions alone. But then again, if majority of Malay Muslims don’t understand Arabic nor even bother to take the time to read the Quran with an aim at understanding it, then it is quite obvious then how such ‘confusion’ could come about. But if so that that is the case, then who’s fault is it then if a people of that religion does not even bother to read or understand the Book of their own religion?
For non-Muslims and non-Malays living in Malaysia all this while, sometimes seeing the Quran being read on national television, or even hear it being read out aloud in public from nearby mosques before Muslim prayer times may actually have thought that all this while Malays in general, actually know or understand Arabic, but this is far from the truth.
This raises the question in-fact as to the way Islam is being taught and practiced in
As I have to admit as a Muslim myself, at times, I feel a great lost being unable to understand or be fluent in Arabic, represents a great challenge as well as a barrier in fully understanding the teaching of Islam or the Quran which is in Arabic itself.
Majority of Muslim Malays since very early childhood are merely being taught how to familiarize themselves with the Arabic Alphabets and writing and taught mainly how to ‘recite’ or ‘pronounce’ the Quran properly, and to recite in terms of pronunciations of the Arabic words properly, but not much emphasis is given into understanding the very ‘meanings’ of the words or even verses of the Quran by Muslims Malays in general for a long time, and this is in-fact how Islam has been taught and practiced for such a long time in Malaysia, where majority of Muslim Malays merely know how to ‘pronounce’ the Quranic verses in Arabic without ever truly comprehend or understand any of it’s meaning –unless their Muslim parents had emphasized their children in taking up proper Islamic studies and on learning Arabic from a very young age.
In terms of religious theology, for non-Muslims out there who are ‘curious’ as pertaining to some of the verses from the Quran which I have cited in here, which mentions such prophets which are familiar to Christians and those of the Judaism faith, this is because in Islamic theology and stand-point is that the Quran itself as well as Islam is continuation of revelations which came before.
In Islam, there are 5 books which came down in various stages, whereby the Quran is the summary and final chapter of the revelations which came down to 5 main prophets beginning with the Prophet and Patriarch “Ibrahim” or Abraham who’s book is mention in the Quran, but has been lost as mentioned in the Quran…
Chapter 53 Surah Al-Najm ( The Stars ) verse 33-37:
33. See you one who turns back, 34. Gives a little, then hardens ( his heart )
35. What! Has he knowledge of the Unseen so that he can see? 36. Nay, is he not acquainted with what is in the books of Moses -37. And of Abraham who fulfilled his engagement?
Chapter 87 Surah Al-A’la ( The Most High ) verses 18-19:
18. And this is in the Books of the earliest ( Revelations ),- 19 The Books of Abraham and Moses.
These 5 books and 5 major prophets are:
5 Major Prophets & Books in Islam:
Abraham/Ibrahim - ( na- )
Moses/Musa - ( Torah/ Taurat )
David/Daud - ( Psalms/ Zabur )
Jesus/Isa - ( Gospels, Evangels/ Injeel )
Muhammad SAW - ( Quran, Koran )
For is is written in Islam in the Quran…
Chapter 43 Surah Al-Ra’d ( The Thunder ) verse 38:
‘ We did send messengers before you, and appointed for them wives and children: and it was never the part of a messenger to bring a Sign except as GOD permitted ( or commanded ). For each period is a Book ( revealed ).’
It is for this very reason why Muslims are commanded by Allah to profess Chapter 2 verse 136 in the Quran which I have cited earlier as Islam is part of the Abrahamic faiths.
For it is written in the Quran…
Chapter 2 Al-Baqarah ( The Heifer ) verse 130:
‘ And who turns away from the religion of Abraham but such as debase their sould with folly? Him We chose and rendered pure in this world: and he will be in the Hereafter in the ranks of the Righteous.’
Muslims in Islam believe in 24-25 major prophets, by which Islam share 20 in common with those of the Christian faith, these prophets and their names in Arabic in The Quran in comparison with the same figures in Bible are:
24 Prophets in Islam:
Bible ( Quranic Equivalent or In the Quran ONLY -IN BLUE colored )
Adam (Adam )
Enoch ( Idris )
Noah (Nuh )
Abraham (Ibrahim )
Ishmael (Ismail )
Isaac (Is’hak )
Jacob (Ya’qub )
Joseph (Yusuf )
Moses (Musa )
Aaron (Harun )
David (Daud )
Solomon (Sulaiman )
Elijah ( Ilyas )
Elisha (Ilyasa )
Job (Ayub )
Jonah (Yunus )
(Salih )
(Hood )
(Syu’ayb )
Zechariah ( Zakaria )
John The Baptist (Yahya )
Jesus ( Isa )
(Muhammad PBUH )
In fact 3 other prophets such as Isaiah and Jeremiah are mentioned in Chapter 17 of the Quran in reference to The Fall of Jerusalem but are not mentioned by name, including the prophet Samuel ( Syamil = Arabic ) as it is written in the Quran…
Chapter 40 Surah Ghafir ( Forgiver ) also known as Surah Al-Mu’min ( The Believer ) verse 78:
‘ We did aforetime send messengers before you: of them are some whose story We have related to you, and some whose story We have not related to you. It was not possible for any messenger to bring a Sign except by leave of GOD: but when the Command of GOD was issued, the matter was decided in truth and justice, and there perished, there and then, those who stood on Falsehoods’.
As for some Christians or Non-Muslims out there who may possess the full English translation copy of the Quran without the Arabic text by ‘Abdullah Yusuf Ali’, some may question concerning some of the stories narrated pertaining to 3 particular prophets mentioned which are the prophets Salih, Hud and Syaib, and pertaining to the people they were sent to which were the people of Ad, their descendents the people of Thamud and Madyan.
But this in-fact is also related and linked directly to The Bible and Abraham as the translations used by Abdullah Yusuf Ali is still in Arabic. The people of Ad in the Bible are in-fact the people of the
Chapter 89 Surah Al-Fajr ( The Break of Dawn ) verses 6-9:
‘6. See you not how your LORD dealt with the Ad ( people ) 7. Of the City of Iram, with lofty pillars, 8. The like of which were not produced in ( all ) the land? 9. And the Thamud ( people ), who cut out
( huge ) rocks in the valley?’
One could see reference to them in the Bible’s Old Testament where it is written in..
Chronicles 1: 51-54
‘The Chiefs of
‘Timna, Alvah, Jetheth, 52. Oholibamah, Elah, Pinon. 53. Kenaz, Teman, Mibzar,
54. Magdiel and Iram. These were the chiefs of
Ancient Kingdom of Israel, to the South in YELLOW, the Kingdom of Edom or people of Ad mentioned in both the Bible's Old Testament and in the Quran
Further reference to them is written in a prophecy against
Jeremiah Chapter 49: 15-18
15. “Now I will make you small among the nations,
despised among men.
16. The terror you inspire and the pride of your heart have deceived you,
you who live in the clefts of the rocks,
who occupy the heights of the hill.
Though you build your nest as high as the eagle’s.
from there I will bring you down.”
declares The LORD
17. “
all who pass by will be appalled and will scoff because of all its wounds.
18. As
along with their neighbouring towns,”
declares The LORD
“ so no one will live there;
No man will dwell in it.”
In The Book of Jeremiah 49: 19-21 further the prophesy writes…
“ I will chase
Who is the chosen one I will appoint for this?”
20. Therefore hear what the LORD has planned against
what HE has purposed against those who live in Teman:
The young of the flock will be dragged away;
HE will completely destroy their pasture because of them.
21. At the sound of their fall the earth will tremble;
their cry will resound to
This prophecy which was written in the Bibles Old Testament had indeed come to pass and is narrated in the Quran which answers the question put forth in Jeremiah 49:19.
The prophet sent by GOD to the people of Edom ( Ad ) was the prophet Hud mentioned in the Quran, whereas to their descendants the Temanites ( Thamud ) later on GOD had sent the prophet Salih both whom were from their own brethren and people who had come to warn them to return to the worship of the one true GOD. The people of Edom and Teman had diverged from their original worship towards GOD and became Pagans just as The Children of Israel had took up idol worship during the time of the Prophet Elijah ( Ilyas ) and Elisha ( Ilyasa ) during the reign of King Ahab and Queen Jezebel or Isreal.
Both prophets Salih and Hud who had came to warn their own people to turn from their ways were rejected and the prophecy in Jeremiah 49: 21 was fulfilled, as it is written in the Quran concerning the people of Teman ( Thamud )…
Chapter 7 Surah Al-A’raf ( The Heights ) verse 78:
‘ So the earthquake took them unawares, and they lay prostrate in their homes in the morning.’
GOD had saved the prophet Hud and Salih, but their cities and their brethren, their own people whom they were sent as messengers to were completely destroyed. Just as the people of the prophet Noah, as well as the prophet Lot ( Lut ); the cousin to Abraham – of
Mark 6: 4-6:
4.Jesus said to them. “Only in his hometown, among his relatives and his own house is a prophet without honor” 5. He could not do any miracles there, except lay his hands on a few sick people and heal them 6. And he was amazed at their lack of faith.
In Islam, Muslims believe Jesus to be a prophet, and a very powerful one. And as the narration of most prophets mentioned in the Quran, many of the prophets of old who were sent to their very own people were rejected, including the prophet Muhammad ( PBUH ) himself who was rejected in the beginning by his own people, the early Pagan Arab Tribes of Quraish in
What remnants of Archeological remains of the People of Edom and Teman today can still be seen, which is the infamous ruins of The City of Petra today…
Ruins of the Ancient City of Petra. The Kingdom of Edom or Ad today...
Remains of the Ancient Tombs of Petra today...
But as seen from the prophecies in The Book of the prophet Jeremiah in the Old Testament, this is why the very verses of the Quran
Chapter 46 Al-Ahqaf ( Winding Sand-tracts ) verse 12:
“ And before this, was the Book of Moses as a guide and mercy: and this Book confirms
( it ) in the Arabic tongue: to admonish the unjust, and as Glad Tidings to those who do right.”
As much of the Old Testament which includes The Psalms, The Torah and the Book of the Prophets and the Deuteronomic History focuses and follows narrations of the history of the Children of Israel and Jews, by which Jesus himself was also a Jew.
The Quran is a continuation that confirms what had came before it, including the prophecies which had been written in the Books of the Prophets which came before as seen from the prophecies against the people of
For some Muslims who do not truly study the Quran itself, may also not be aware how the story of the people of
Amongst the other reasons why the Quran stresses the fact that the Quran is a confirmation of the previous scriptures in the Arabic language also relates to a verse in the Quran…
Chapter 30 Al-Rum ( The
“ And among His Signs is the creation of the heavens and the earth, and the variations in your languages and your colours: verily in that are Signs for those who know.”
For amongst the reasons of how it is repeated in the Quran in Chapter 43 Al-Zukhruf ( The Gold Adornments ) verse 3, as well as Chapter 39 Al-Zumar ( The Crowds ) verse 28, this in-fact relates to the study of linguistics itself and the evolution of language.
As the prophet Abraham ( Ibrahim ) himself was from
The Great Ziggurat of UR today
Remains of the Royal Tombs of UR today
As with most languages, throughout the course of times, languages evolve and change, but may still retain some shared words from their original tongue and may vary slightly. Similarly to how Indonesian and the Malay ‘Bahasa Melayu’ may be very similar but also have their own unique variations. As could be seen from the comparison between Aramaic Alphabets below ( on the left ) with their equivalents in Hebrew and Arabic; both Hebrew and Arabic still retain or use some of the original letters.
Hebrew evolved and retained some of the original Imperial Aramaic alphabets,
Whereas although modern day Arabic uses some of the similar letters, some pronounced differently, but Arabic uses the Persian Text for writing, but some of the letters are still the same.
From LEFT Imperial Aramaic Alphabet Letters, Middle, same letters in Hebrew Far RIGHT, same letters in Arabic using Persian Text Alphabets.
The pronunciations of some of the letters may vary in modern Arabic a bit, such as the letter ‘Beth’ in Aramaic & Hebrew is pronounced as ‘Ba’, the letter ‘Lamedh’, in Aramaic and Hebrew, would pronounced as ‘Lam’ in Arabic.
Thus there are slight variations, for example the word itself ‘Beth’ Aramaic and Hebrew, in Arabic would be pronounced as ‘Bai’t’ which in both languages means ‘House’. The word “Shemesh”, in Aramaic and Hebrew, would be pronounced as “Shams” in Arabic which both means “Sun”. “Elohim” in Aramaic and Hebrew, in Arabic would be pronounced as “Al-Raheem”, which is one of GOD’s name in Islam meaning “Most Merciful”. Thus for example the place of Jesus ( Isa ) birth ‘
Thus the Old Hebrew word “Eloah” for God, in Arabic on the other hand, would be pronounced as “Allah”.
But the very word “Eloah” and “Allah” derives from a much older word in Aramaic for GOD which is “El” or “Il”.
In Ancient Babylon, “El” represented the main GOD, or ‘creator’ GOD who sits high in heaven, whom in Ancient Babylonian religion before the time of the prophet Abraham, was said to be the ‘Father God’, who was father to infamous Pagan Gods that appear in both the Bible and the Quran…the father to ‘Baal’ and ‘Asherah’. But the word “El” in Aramaic is also a generic or plural term for GOD. Notice that the very names of the Angels in Islam and Christianity are also in-fact Aramaic in nature. For example
GabriEL or Jibrail in Arabic ( The EL in the back signifying GOD ), as well as the EL in the middle of the word
The Babylonian Gate of Ishtar, excavated and reconstructed in the Museum of Berlin today...
One theory states that the Ancient Greeks ‘borrowed’ this word as it’s Greek variant which is used in English today is “Pavillion”.
The Angel Gabriel or Jibrail, the very word Gaber is variant of the Arabic word with Aramaic roots of “Jabbar” meaning “Magnificent”, “Ra” on the other hand is believed to be the old word for “Light” in Ancient Aramaic, shared by early Egyptians who’s Kingdom arose several centuries later on. This is consistent where in Islam, it written that GOD had created Angels from light. Thus The Angel Gabriel or Jibrail’s name literally means”
“Magnificent Light of God”.
This name is consistent with the Angel Gabriel ( Jibrails ) position as the leader to all the Angels and according to Islam, is also the bringer of GOD’s light who brings down the ‘scriptures’ from GOD to the prophets or in Islam the bringer of ‘wahyu’.
Furthermore, Muslims and even those non-Muslims who may hold the full English Translation Copy of the Quran without the Arabic texts by Abdullah Yusuf Ali, may notice how some of the very verses of the Quran begin with the Arabic letters, Aleph, Lam, Mim…
As it is also written in the Quran in
Chapter 2 Surah Al-Baqarah ( The Heifer ) verse 146:-
‘ The People of the Book know this as they know their own sons…
But these very letters if translated into their Aramaic equivalent as given above…
would be pronounced as Aleph, Lamedh, Mem…these letters could be found in the 3rd Book of Revelation given the Prophet & King David ( Daud ), in The Psalms ( Zabur ). Where with each letter is written a psalm or a prayer found where it is written in Chapter 119…
Psalms 119: 1-8
‘Aleph’
1 Blessed are they whose ways are Blameless,
Who walk according to the Law of the LORD,
2 Blessed are they who keep HIS statutes
And seek HIM with all their heart.
3.They do nothing wrong ;
They walk in HIS ways.
4.YOU have laid down precepts
That are to be fully obeyed.
5 Oh that my ways were steadfast
In obeying your decrees!
6 Then I would not be put to shame
When I consider your commands.
7 I will praise you with an upright heart
As I learn you righteous laws
8 I will obey your decrees:
Do not utterly forsake me.
Psalms 119: 89-96
‘Lamedh’
89 YOUR word O LORD is eternal
It stands firms in the heavens.
90 YOUR faithfulness continues through all generations
YOU establish the earth, and it endures.
91 YOUR laws endure to this day,
For all things serve YOU.
92 If YOUR law had not been my delight,
I would have perished in my affliction.
93 I will never forget YOUR precepts
for by them you have preserved my life.
94 Save me for I am YOURS;
I have sought out YOUR precepts.
95 The wicked are waiting to destroy me,
But I will ponder YOUR statutes.
96 To all perfection I see a limit;
But YOUR commands are boundless.
Psalms 119: 97-104
‘Mem’
97 Oh, how I love YOUR law!
I meditate on it all day long.
98 YOUR commands make me wiser than my enemies,
For they are ever with me.
99 I have more insight than all my teachers,
For I meditate on YOUR statutes
100 I have more understanding than the elders,
For I obey YOUR precepts.
101 I have kept my feet from every evil path,
So that I might obey YOUR word.
102 I have not departed from YOUR laws,
For YOU YOURself have taught me.
103 How sweet are YOUR words to my taste,
Sweeter than honey to my mouth!
104 I gain understanding from YOUR precepts;
Therefore I hate every wrong path.
This alone shows the link as well as continuity of the Quran as a confirmation of previous scriptures that came before it, as well as a linguistic continuity in a language with Semitic roots that are shared, just as it had been written as clue in the Quran itself…
“ And among His Signs is the creation of the heavens and the earth, and the variations in your languages and your colours: verily in that are Signs for those who know.”
But as it has been said concerning those who seek to find answers…
“Ask and it will be given to you, seek and you will find; knock and the door will be opened to you. For everyone who asks, receives; he who seeks finds; and to him who knocks, the door will be opened.”
Further it is written in the Quran itself…
Chapter 2 Surah Al-Baqarah ( The Heifer ) verse 269:
‘He grants wisdom to whom He pleases; and he to whom wisdom is granted receives
indeed a benefit overflowing; but none will grasp the Message but men of
understanding.”
If much has already been made cleared and explained to Muslims within the Quran, then where exactly can there be any confusion or could the so called claimed ‘confusion’ then stem from?
But as I have mentioned previously, since Arabic is not the primary nor even secondary language of Malays, this in-fact answers most of the questions put forth. As even the Malay language also borrows many words from Arabic itself, and even the original founder of Melacca Parameswara himself only embraced Islam at a much later age, whereas before the coming of Islam itself, much of the Malay Peninsular previously was originally of the Hindu faith.
A matter of fact, sadly to say, much of Malay Traditions and customs till today, such as the belief in traditional Malay shaman’s such as Bomohs or Pawangs, even the wearing of ‘Inai’ or 'Henna'on the hands and fingers of Malay women to be wed, or even traditions pertaining to beliefs in the use or wearing of charms by Malays or Tangkal to ward off bad-luck or demons, or even traditional beliefs pertaining to the traditional Malay dagger –the Keris. Much of these beliefs and traditions themselves are not part of Islamic religion and teaching and some in-fact even go against Islamic teaching, as some of these very beliefs are more of traditional pre-Islamic beliefs which have roots in Animism which are not aligned with Islam’s belief or teaching, but still are being followed or practiced by Malay Muslims till today.
'Henna' a non-Islamic tradition still practiced by Malay Muslims till today
Even the Malay tradition when facing the Malay Kings or Sultans or ‘Sembah Raja’ where one is required to lift their hands up to their heads to hail the Malay Kings or Sultans itself is from ancient pre-Islamic tradition which is a practice that is from pre-Islamic times, similar to the way Ancient Hindu’s used to hail the Raja’s of Old. Whereas greetings in accordance to Islam is to embrace one another, which is how the Kings or Royals of the middle-east also practice.
Thus before the very coming of Islam to Malay Peninsular itself, Malays used merely the word ‘Tuhan’ to denote GOD. It was after the coming of Islam itself to the Malay Peninsular, that the very word ‘Allah’ itself used by Malay Muslims of today is also taken from Arabic itself and became a more specific word to denote GOD in Islam by Malay Muslims, whereas in the Middle-East and among Arab Muslims and Christians, Allah is the word used for GOD in general. Which is why this particular issue, is in-fact not really much of an issue among Arabic speaking countries, it is in-fact an issue and made into a problem which was politicized because of the way Malays in particular utilize the word to denote something more specific, thus making it an issue because Malays in general do not speak Arabic.
Although Malays claim to read the very Quran itself…which by way of practice in
Sadly even among the much elder Malays, when they ‘listen’ or hear the Quran on television or even playing it on a CD in their cars, basically their listening to it’s intonation like someone listening to a song. And when asked… they would say,
‘Sedap bacaan dia!’ or ‘The way it’s being read is nice!’ …as if they were listening to a song or a hymn but not even understanding the very meanings of the verses they are listening to. Thus the very message of the Quran to Malay Muslims is lost. But as the Prophet Muhammad ( PBUH ) once prophesized concerning among the signs of The End of Times is ‘when the Quran is being sung like a song.’ This is in-fact sadly how a vast majority of non-Arabic Malay Muslims practice the Quran today, when it has been written clearly in the Quran…
Chapter 36 Ya’Sin verse 69:
‘We have not instructed ( the Prophet ) in Poetry, nor is it meet for him: this no less than a Message and a Qur’an making things clear.’
Although many Malay Muslims often recite this particular Chapter of the Quran during many festivities or special occasions, but sadly they fail to recognize this particular ayat.
But the teaching of Islam among Muslims is in-fact very much in contrast even in comparison to the way Islam is being taught in Mainland
But what has happened to the very quality of Islamic Education in
'Mat Rempits'...illegal street racers, evidence of degradation of Moral Values among Malay Muslim Youth in Malaysia today
Gambling is forbidden in Islam, though it doesn't seem much of a problem for this particular Malay individual...
Malay Youth wearing a T-Shirt with obscene English writing while praying in a mosque
The very proper education of Islam under decades of racial based politics under UMNO has in-fact made it much more susceptible for the Federal Government under UMNO’s leadership to conduct racially biased courses that promote racism and segregation such as courses conducted by the National Civics Bureau or Malaysia or BTN, which if Malays in general had a more grounded knowledge of Islamic Education and on matters pertaining to Morals in accordance to Islamic Principles, they would know that racial segregation and racism itself is wrong and is in-fact against the very teachings of Islam as even the Prophet Muhammad ( PBUH ) himself had once said:
‘He is not one of us who proclaims the cause of tribal partisanship; and he is not one of us who fights in the cause of tribal partisanship; and he is not of us who dies for the sake of tribal partisanship.’
Thus for decades under UMNO leadership, the Government had taken major steps to control as well as regulate the proper teachings of Islam to general public, particularly due to the fact that the vast majority of Muslims in Malaysia are Malays, who represent the main targeted voters and supporters needed by UMNO.
These actions had included the control of edited sermons during muslim Friday prayers.The prohibition of members of the opposition party PAS from conducting courses, talks or even seminars in State or Federally built mosques. The regulation and monitoring of ‘fatwa’s’ or Islamic Advice issued by State ‘Mufti’s’ or Islamic State Religious Officials who are suppose to give counsel in accordance to Islamic Principles. And during the reign of the former Prime Minister Dr. Mahathir Mohammed, the closing down of Islamic Community Schools or ‘Sekolah Agama Rakyat’. As what has been a common-trend in-fact, many Malays who properly delve into Islamic studies and issues of morality in Islam most often end-up opposing UMNO as a political party and not supporting much of it’s racially biased policies and due to rampant corruption of the party itself, end up questioning the leaders of UMNO’s very own morality itself. Thus for these particular reasons, to stem any further support towards PAS as a political party or towards opposition, the Federal Government under UMNO has always highly regulated any issues pertaining to the spread or even teaching of Islam for a long time to the general public in order to maintain it’s very own position of power in Malaysia. While always preaching progress among Malays and the nation, but sadly, such progress only means materialism alone and not any spiritual progress of Malays as individuals or Muslims or any progress in terms morality in the very face of modernization. Whereby for quite a long time, PAS has always stressed much upon putting moral values ahead of material progress as what is taught and stressed upon in Islamic teaching itself.
But sadly, these regulatory actions which have been practiced by UMNO itself has come at a cost towards the Malay society in general, as throughout the decades under UMNO leadership, what every Malay as well as Malaysians could see quite clearly, is the degradation of moral values among the Malay youth in general, where much of the Social Ills in Malaysia today, from illegal racing on the streets of Malaysia giving rise to youths called Mat Rempits, to young juveniles almost equivalent to biker-chicks cum prostitutes called Boh-Sias, to the majority of those in rehabilitation for drug abuse, as well as to many cases of murder of newly born babies out-of-wedlock or infanticide. If one takes a look at the statistics, the majority of these cases of Social Ills within
But it is because of the rapid decadence of morality in Malay society today, that many Malays who place precedence towards the issue of morality as their priority, and see proper and quality education and teaching of religion as one of the answers to these social ills, that many Malays choose to support PAS instead of UMNO. As UMNO has quite often choose to avoid the issues of morality as well as proper teachings of religion, as UMNO’s own existence as well as racially biased policies are against Islamic teachings.
Furthermore, with the rampant practice of corruption in UMNO itself, one merely needs to ask…
‘Can leaders who are themselves without any sense or morals or morality,
While some of the more ignorant among Malay Muslims would like to claim that the very utilization of the word ‘Allah’ by People of The Book among Christians in Malaysia could cause confusion by using the example of wayward religious cults such as the Ayah Pin incident as a poor example, but what most Malays have failed to see is religious cults which had arisen in Malaysia in the past such as Al-Arqam, Ayah Pin, or even the Rasul Melayu… a guy claiming himself to be a Malay prophet, these incidents had nothing to do with other religious influence or dogma. These were all Malays who were born and raised as Muslims themselves.
The rise of particular wayward religious cults in Malaysia which were based upon Islamic teachings, including the recent extremist actions of attacks on Churches across Malaysia have only proven in-fact two things only:-
1-The extremely poor level of Basic Fundamental Islamic Education in
as being taught to Malays in general, without the inclusion or aim at understanding
the Arabic texts of the Quran which it has been preserved and written in, or with a
view towards issues pertaining to Ethics and Morality in accordance to the
principles of Islam itself.
2-Under 50 years of racial and racist based politics,
of Islam is in-fact not truly aligned with the way Islam is taught or even practiced
in other Muslim countries internationally. This has been proven by the fact that
even the leader of the International Islamic Ulama or Teachers Association
Yusuf Al-Qardawi himself had also said that the use of the word Allah for
denoting GOD by People of the Book was allowed. But despite Sheikh Yusuf Al-
Qardawi’s visit to
also President of the leading racist party UMNO- had took the time to take pictures
with him which was published on the front page of UMNO’s owned nationally
circulated newspaper Utusan Malaysia. But the very advice of the world’s most
renowned Islamic Scholar himself had been ignored purposely. Nor did or has
the Prime Minister himself even during his visits the
for Islamic practice and studies worldwide- seek to clarify the issue pertaining to
the use of the word Allah by People of the Book from some of the world’s top
religious scholars. Which paints the picture that the whole incident was purposely
politicized by UMNO in order to cause religious tensions and friction in
as another cheap way of gaining supporters among the Malays which represent
the majority race and main targeted voters and supporters needed by the UMNO
party.
Another most prevalent aspect which one could also see of the opinions of Malay Muslims in Malaysia concerning the whole Allah issue is the very absence towards the teaching or spreading of the true message of Islam to non-Muslims in Malaysia or Islamic missionary movements also known as Da’wah. With the very constitutional definition of Islam in
But the situation with the lack of Islamic missionary movements or da’wah could also be seen both a cause from 50 years of political confusion under UMNO’s reign as well as a state of religious complacency which is clearly explained in Rodney Stark’s infamous book ‘Discovering God’ which explains the rise and fall of Ancient Religions since the early Sumerian and Egyptian times, to the rise of both Islam and Christianity.
In Rodney Stark’s book written from a more academic perspective shows how the theory of religious markets work, how people are attracted to religions, the theory of religious capital which accounts for how much easier it is for people to convert to certain religions compared to others. The most interesting factor mentioned is how complacency in a religious practice usually kicks in when a Religion is heavily sponsored or subsidized by the State, where the leaders of the religious practice who’s income is also sponsored or even subsidized by the State, thus there is not much motivation or the feel of the very need to attract new converts to the religion or even spread the religious teachings to other’s who are not of the faith, as the State religion as well as the religious officials do not need donations from it’s congregation in order to support it’s movements.
This is much different in comparison with religions which are not sponsored or subsidized by the State, who’s missionary movements have to be more active in attracting new converts and followers to their cause, as much of the movement or places of worship are financed through charitable donations given by it’s congregation and these non-subsidized or sponsored religions are also more active as a ‘community’ or people.
One could already see the very complacency in the teaching or spread of the true Islamic teachings in Malaysia by Malays to other non-Muslims or non-Malays, which aside from the heavy regulation towards Islamic practice and faith in Malaysia, plus with the complacency that comes when everything is fully sponsored by the State Government, but another factor which is also political which can be seen is that…if a Non-Malay converts to Islam in Malaysia, most often he/she could qualify after some time as bumiputra status, so long as he/she speaks the Malay language and practices Malay traditions/culture such as what has happened to many Muslim converts who married with Malay-Muslims.
Looking at UMNO’s ideology, it has always portrayed itself as the protector of the Malays and Malay rights from other races, especially the Chinese and sometimes even Indians whom have been often demonized by UMNO. UMNO has for decades taught Malays that if they do not support UMNO, Chinese, Indians and other races who are the minorities would take over
Thus the complacency towards the spread or teaching of the true Islamic teachings
or Da’wah –missionary movements-could easily be related to UMNO’s dominant strategy of using fear politics towards gaining Malay support, as in order for UMNO to survive, and remain relevant in today’s 21st Century, it needs a clear visible enemy to continually promote the fear and enmity among Malays towards other races or even religions, so that Malays will continue to depend on UMNO to protect it. If a vast majority of Chinese, Indians, people of Sabahan’s or Sarawakians were to convert or become Muslims…then with their ability to speak bahasa –the Malay language-, they would qualify later on as bumiputra’s and of course UMNO would no longer have any enemies for it to continue to remain relevant. Thus the tactic or strategy of keeping Malay Muslims ignorant is in-fact a tactic which only works to UMNO’s own advantage, but at the expense of the entire country’s image, the image of Islam at an international level, and of course at the expense of dishonoring the entire Malay race Internationally, which UMNO has for a long time had great talent of doing continuously with the kind of silly and ignorant remarks which quite often comes out of the mouths of UMNO Ministers themselves.
But this complacency which one could easily see in the Islamic practice in
The Quran also writes in reference to People of the Book among Jews and Christians:
Chapter 5 Al-Ma’idah ( The Table ) verse 19:-
‘ O People of The Book! Now has come unto you, making things clear unto you, Our Messenger, after the break in ( the series of ) Our messengers, lest you should say: “There came unto us no bringer of glad tidings and a warner ( from evil ). And GOD has power over all things.’
In the Quran there are several in-fact verses which address Christians and Jews directly as People of the Book such as the one above. But HOW are Christians or Jews going to know or find out, unless either the buy a translation copy of the Quran itself, or if a person who is a Muslim themselves bother or even take the time to explain about Islam to them or relay the message such as the verse above to them?
Thus when one considers the implications of Malay Muslims in Malaysia due to ignorance by NOT allowing People of the Book among Christians or even Jews to use the word ‘Allah’ for God, one should consider how their actions clearly contradict everything that has been taught within the Quran itself:-
1st – Denying People of the Book the right to use the word ‘Allah’ is equivalent to
denying that GOD or ‘Allah’ himself had indeed sent messengers and scriptures
before the coming of Islam itself, and that those messengers were from GOD
or ‘Allah’ himself as well as denying that Christians and Jews are indeed
‘People of the Book’ when nowhere in the Quran does GOD or ‘Allah’ deny
that they are not People of the Book as which could be seen clearly from
Chapter 22 Al-Hajj ( The Pilgrimage ) verse 39-40 quoted above.
2nd- Denying People of the Book the right to use the word ‘Allah’ would also
be equivalent to differentiating between the prophets themselves which
clearly goes against GOD or ‘Allah’s’ command to Muslims in
Chapter 2 Al-Baqarah ( The Heifer ) verse 136 as what I have cited
above.
3rd- The Federal Government under UMNO’s very own actions in trying to
Appeal against the High Courts rule also clearly goes against GOD or
‘Allah’s’ own command in the Quran as written in Chapter 29 Al-Ankabut
( The Spider ) verse 46. As Christians do believe that there is ONE GOD,
it is only the ‘identity’ of God in Islam which differs with that of Christian
theology. But as the difference in both religious theologies have already been
written in a clear and concise manner, then there would not be any confusions
if Malays as Muslims truly read and understood their own Quran….
Whatever differences there may be, that would in-fact be a Muslims
responsibility in Islam to explain it, which majority of Malays as Muslims
sadly don’t even bother to do so as they’ve always been taught by
the government under UMNO to make enemies and hate everybody
from other races and other religions.
4th- To deny People of the Book among Christians the right to use the word
‘Allah’ in relation to the 1st point I have put forth is also equivalent to
Malays as Muslims implying that there is another GOD besides Allah
for Christians and Jews who were responsible for the earlier messengers
and scriptures that came before, and this by itself is already against
Islamic religion which teaches that there is NO GOD but Allah ( GOD )
or ONE God.
5th- To continue with the appeal and to deny People of the Book in
right to use the word ‘Allah’ for GOD would also paint a bad image for
Malaysian Muslims in general at an International level, as from the recent
incidents of Church burning and even the UMNO led government protesting
against the People of the Book using it, many Arab speaking Muslims from
The Middle-East are already questioning and beginning to believe that
Malays in
Their own ‘Malaysian’ or UMNOrized version of Islam which is not the
same as what Middle-Eastern muslims practice as the standard Islamic
practice as they have no problems with Christians in the Middle-East using
the word ‘Allah’ which means GOD.
Even the very claim that the use of the word would ‘confuse’ Muslims is unfounded, especially when the Quran itself has made everything clear for Muslims itself thus where is the confusion?
UMNO’s very own call for an Islam Hadhari which received no protests by majority of Malays supporting UMNO itself during the tenure of Tun Hj. Abdullah Ahmad Badawi as Prime Minister of Malaysia in-fact was even MORE confusing as many till today wanted to know what was difference with the regular practice of Islam?
But if UMNO continues with it’s plan to appeal and even State Governments themselves merely follow suit, then it would only be at Islam as a religion’s own future detriment as they would make missionary or da’wah movements in Islam in the future much harder and in-fact dissuade even more non-Muslims to being attracted to understanding, finding out or even learning about the true teachings of Islam, as the Malaysian Government’s own policy clearly now practices religious segregation in addition to it’s racial segregation policies.
There would clearly be no confusion if Malays as Muslims simply followed what has been written in the Quran..
Chapter 6 Surah Al-An’am ( The Cattle ) verse 155:
‘ And this is a Book which We have revealed as a blessing: so follow it and be righteous, that you may receive mercy.’
But then again, how could a people who clearly don’t understand the Arabic language,
nor even bother to find out or understanding the Books meanings be able to follow something which they cannot comprehend? And how are a people like the Malays to understand their own religion, when they have a political party in Government that intentionally tries to make sure that Malays don’t truly understand their own religion for the political parties own benefit?
Some thoughts to ponder….
Imran
